Buying
Art and money, honestly
Art is sold with the suggestion that it will make you money. Almost none of it does, and the people who say so are rarely the ones taking the risk.
The claim, and what is wrong with it
You will hear that art is an asset class, that it outperforms equities, that the market grew by some striking percentage last year. Those figures are usually drawn from auction results, and auction results describe a very small, very particular slice of the art world: works by established names, resold at the top of the market, where there was a buyer. Pieces that did not sell do not appear in the index. Neither does the overwhelming majority of art, which is never resold at all.
So the honest summary is this. A small number of works by a small number of artists appreciate dramatically. Most paintings, by most painters, hold modest value or less, and they are slow and awkward to sell when you want to. That is not a reason to avoid buying art. It is a reason not to buy it as a financial instrument.
I am a painter, not a financial adviser, and nothing here is advice about your money. But I would rather say this plainly than let you buy a painting of mine for the wrong reason.
The costs nobody mentions
If you did treat a painting as an investment, you would have to count the whole picture:
- Framing and glazing, which can be a substantial fraction of the purchase price.
- Insurance, if the piece is worth insuring.
- Shipping, which for anything large is expensive and risky.
- Selling costs. A gallery or auction house takes a significant share of the sale price, and a private sale takes your time and your contacts.
- Illiquidity. You cannot sell a painting on a Tuesday afternoon because you need the money.
Against all of that, a painting pays no dividend. What it pays is in a currency that does not convert: you get to look at it every day.
What is actually true about value
Several things are true at once, and the useful move is to hold them together rather than pick one.
An original holds value differently from a reproduction. A mass-produced print has a resale value of essentially nothing the moment it leaves the shop. An original by a working artist with a real exhibition record retains something, and in many cases retains most of what you paid. Not growth — retention. That alone makes it a different kind of purchase from furniture.
Prices do rise as an artist's career develops. If a painter is working steadily, exhibiting, selling, and being collected by institutions, their prices generally move upward over the years, and work bought earlier was bought cheaper. This is real, and it is the honest version of the investment story. It is also unpredictable, slow, and no use to you unless you are prepared to sell.
Some markets are genuinely underpriced relative to the work. Caribbean painting is one. Jamaican artists with decades of practice, formal training and international sales behind them price well below artists of comparable standing working in New York or London, for reasons of geography and market access rather than quality. If value is on your mind, that gap is the interesting fact, not any index.
What to do instead
Buy work you want to live with, at a price you are comfortable having spent whatever happens next. Then value is a bonus rather than a condition, and you cannot be disappointed by a market you were not relying on.
If you want to be sensible about it as well, a few things cost you nothing:
- Buy originals rather than open-edition prints, if the budget allows it.
- Keep the paperwork. Receipt, certificate, any correspondence, photographs. Provenance is most of what establishes value later, and it is almost always the thing that got lost.
- Buy from the artist or from someone who can tell you exactly where the piece came from.
- Look after it properly. Condition is the other half of value, and sun and damp do more damage to the worth of a painting than any market ever will.
- Buy work by painters who are still working. A living artist with an active practice is still building the record that any future value rests on.
The only reliable return on a painting is the thirty seconds a day you spend looking at it. Over twenty years that is a great deal of looking, and it is the part no one can take away from you.
A word on commissions and collecting
If you find a painter whose work you keep returning to, the most rewarding thing you can do is buy more than one piece over time, and talk to them while you are doing it. That is what collecting actually is — not a portfolio, a relationship with a body of work as it develops. It happens to also be the approach that has historically produced the collections worth something, but that is a side effect, and it should stay one.